30 Bananas a Day!

Ok so here are all the major China Study critiques on the web I'm aware of, see below.

We need some volunteers to do concise summaries of the argument and content of these critiques.

We're looking for commonalities in subject matter (there are plenty as you'll see) so we can address them all (along with Denise's) in one comprehensive rebuttal.

Let me know if you find any others. Thanks folks.

**Format for summaries:

Title of critique:
Thesis:
Summary:
(summary should be done on a point-by-point basis for easy reference)


Chris Masterjohn

"The Truth about the China Study" (2005)
http://www.cholesterol-and-health.com/China-Study.html

"Response to T. Colin Campbell" (2007)
http://www.cholesterol-and-health.com/Campbell-Masterjohn.html

"Denise Minger Refutes the China Study Once and For All" (2010)
http://www.westonaprice.org/blogs/denise-minger-refutes-the-china-s...
(Masterjohn's fawning review of Denise's latest critique)


Anthony Colpo

(originally posted under pseudonym 'JayY')

"The China Study: More Vegan Nonsense!" (2006)
http://www.anthonycolpo.com/the_china_study.html


Dr. Mercola

"Why the China Study is Flawed"
http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2006/02/23/why-t...
(annoyingly you have to subscribe to his mailing list to read the article)

---

Common Themes/Topics

Thought I'd list these here too, I'll start with the ones I'm aware of:

-Idea that saturated fat/animal fat doesn't cause heart disease at all (skepticism of 'lipid hypothesis'), rather it's refined grains and sugars (compare to Denise's assertion based on the China Project data that wheat is more pathogenic/carcinogenic than meat). Also that high cholesterol is good and dietary cholesterol is a nutrient.

-"healthy animal protein" to counter Campbell's assertion that all animal protein is carcinogenic, whey protein isolate is the sole example.

-cultures that eat tons of animal products are healthy/disease free/long lived (e.g. Masai, inuit, Tuoli, etc.)

-vegan diets are inherently unsustainable and/or unhealthy

-raw/free-range/grass-fed animal products do not pose the same health problems as cooked/pasteurized/grain-fed/factory farmed varieties

Views: 309

Replies to This Discussion

oh that's that failed veg tom billings.
he has good stuff to steal from his site, but his 'opinions' are pretty silly.
doug graham made mincemeat out of him here (at least from a debating perspective):
http://www.30bananasaday.com/forum/topics/debate-between-doug-graha...

in friendship,
prad
oh cool!! thanks for this link, prad.
look forward to it robert!
what's colpo so mad about michael eades for?
you'd think he'd be buddies with him for that obfuscating post the guy wrote against campbell:
http://www.proteinpower.com/drmike/cancer/the-china-study-vs-the-ch...

geez! if it weren't for the veg contingent, these corpse eaters would be eating each other!

in friendship,
prad
nice stuff, robert!

creationist is apt terminology for this colpo diatribe ... after all, when one doesn't have science on one's side, there is little else to fall back on other than creative creations. :D

in friendship,
prad
these are extraordinarily good points, robert!
the parallels you draw and then substantiate really are there.

the appeal to nature is certainly one i've come across frequently:
http://www.30bananasaday.com/forum/topics/natural-good

i've heard the most bizarre rationalizations on the noble savage notion too - a remarkable one being how the prey knows when it is time and willingly (even happily) goes to meet its death. i don't know what some of these people have been smoking!

i think the point of your last sentence is really important. we often have arguments here about what ancestors ate and forget that they ate what was there whether it was 'natural' or not. then of course it spirals in to some variation of the is-ought fallacy at a dizzying pace (even here) :D

in friendship,
prad
agreed! species-wide it makes no sense to argue what is an ethical stance via a biological characteristics.

of course, while veganism in its present form is modern, it has existed throughout the ages in various cultures for ethical reasons (though it was termed spiritual back then since 'ethics' as presented now is sort of a modern idea too).

i think one treads into dangerous waters if one tries to argue that one shouldn't eat corpse because our ancestors naturally didn't for biological reasons (because many did despite their biology). it is almost as absurd an argument as what the other side attempts when they say there were no successful vegan cultures in the past (because there were vegans and a culture encompasses a lot of leeway and successful could mean anything - besides, here are 2 problems:
1. since corpse-eating cultures fail like say the huns who are no more, it must mean corpse-eating cultures are failures :D
or
2. since there were always veg in every culture it means there is no such thing as a corpse-eating culture anymore than there is a veg culture :D).

in any case, far better, imho, to stick to keeping

1. physiological arguments physiological (ie human physiology handles veg much better than otherwise and here's why: comparative anatomy)

2. ethical arguments in their own realm (ie the imprisonment, exploitation, abuse and murder of sentient beings just ain't nice)

and let our ancestors lie in peace.

being a recluse, i've worked hard enough just getting rid of my relatives - don't need any ancestors gumming up the works. :D

in friendship,
prad

RSS

About

TheBananaGirl created this Ning Network.

30BaD Search

Latest Activity

Rob is now a member of 30 Bananas a Day!
17 hours ago
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Alex Sunbear's discussion Seeking some fruity friends in Brooklyn/Manhattan in the group NYC and vicinity
yesterday
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Alex Sunbear's discussion Seeking some fruity friends in Brooklyn/Manhattan in the group NYC and vicinity
yesterday
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Alex Sunbear's discussion Seeking some fruity friends in Brooklyn/Manhattan in the group NYC and vicinity
yesterday
Houdini Steve Owens joined TheBananaGirl's group
yesterday
OrganicMark posted a status
"The Other Side of the “Shut Down”: Covert Operations Ongoing to Eviscerate the Deep State [videos] #truth #light #now http://bit.ly/2Fz69R1"
Friday
OrganicMark posted a status
"CONFIRMED: President Trump Can Start Laying Off Furloughed Workers After 30 Days With ‘Reduction In Force’ Procedure http://bit.ly/2RSj0DH"
Friday
ednshell replied to Raw Mormon Mommy's discussion If YOU were diagnosed with CANCER..
Wednesday
pradtf replied to pradtf's discussion great site with nutritional research information
Tuesday
Courtney Beth replied to Raw Mormon Mommy's discussion If YOU were diagnosed with CANCER..
Tuesday
OrganicMark posted a status
"What If This Puerto Rico Trip Is For "Tribunals" For 30 Democrats And 109 Lobbyists?! #peace #truth #love #light #now http://bit.ly/2suXgiY"
Tuesday
Courtney Beth replied to Roar of Tiger's discussion Can 811 rv diet heal cancer?
Tuesday
Courtney Beth replied to Dutchie's discussion Cancer on 811?
Tuesday
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Frugisaurus's discussion Looking for housemate brazil
Jan 14
Profile IconBen and Shaunta Clint joined 30 Bananas a Day!
Jan 12
Frugisaurus posted a discussion
Jan 10

© 2019   Created by TheBananaGirl.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service