30 Bananas a Day!

Post any updates here folks, thanks!

Views: 829

Replies to This Discussion

colin campbell has posted a very fine article:

A Primer on Statistics

it is easily understandable, thorough and instructive!
well-worth the read!

in friendship,
prad
Hi Robert do you mind if I add you to our China Study email list? I think I have your addy. addressing this is one of the projects some us are going to be working on. if you're interested it'd be great to have you involved.
that nice she's put up an html version, but here's the original pdf.

in friendship,
prad
Attachments:
Ned's analysis on colorectal cancer, cholesterol, and schistosomiasis.

Initial post

Post revisited

I've found Ned to be quite professional and I think his analytical skills are solid. He also seems to have an understanding of context. His U-shaped dose-response curve (in the 2nd post) between total cholesterol, in contrast to what Denise insinuates on her own blog regarding Ned's findings, does not discredit Campbell in any way. (By the way, Ned does not suggest that it discredits Campbell.) Campbell was working from a particular model of colorectal cancer based on prior studies, and therefore hypothesized that there would be an upward trend, rather than a U-shaped one. So it is likely it was simply innocently missed. After all, there are hundreds of thousands of combinations of variables (and far more than this if you consider univariable, multivariable, and multivariate analyses!!) in the China Survey data; do we really expect that an exhaustive analysis of every conceivable combination and permutation should have been done by a single team of researchers?
found this in the comments of the 2nd post:
O Primitivo from Canibais e Reis (link below) is putting together several files with the China Study data.

http://www.canibaisereis.com/

With those files anyone interested will be able to play with models ad nauseum.

I have been looking at the bivariate (aka univariate) correlations, and they are very interesting. A lot of confounding variables.

Btw, I delete O Primitivo's comment above at his request. He had included his email and was concerned about spamming.
and a comment from healthycritique:

*********
hi ned, i continue to find your posts to be interesting and professionally presented. a few thoughts...

1. one thing i find challenging in all of this is that we're talking about colorectal cancer *mortality* rather than incidence. and the two are not necessarily directly related; there are other factors related to mortality that do not play a role in incidence (eg. treatment). this of course, applies to anyone undertaking an analysis of the china survey data. therefore, i find it difficult to draw conclusions approaching causality because we're not talking about risk of developing the disease.

2. the mortality rates are for 1975-1977 whereas the exposures were collected in 1983, so there is an even greater issue of temporality than we might normally have in a cross-sectional survey.

3. it is possible - especially since we're using mortality as the outcome - that the u-shaped curve actually reflects some other variable (eg. BMI) that might be subject to some reverse causality.

4. have you considered redoing your analyses using the online data? there are some differences between what denise has posted and what is online (denise was forthright about this). it would also be interesting to see the results for 1989 data, as the chinese population may have started to acquire more 'western' dietary patterns by then.

anyway, nice reading your post!
B launches the first document from our group:
Has Denise Minger Read 'The China Study'? -- A Collective Rebuttal

this is an extensive and precise analysis of the minger criticism of tcs. specifically it presents and substantiates the following 3 areas:

1) The author does not appear to be familiar with many of the objectives, content and key concepts presented in TCS. The intent, message and implications of the book are misrepresented to her readers and strawman arguments abound.

2) In spite of claiming to maintain neutrality, the author shows an unmistakable bias in favor of animal foods in her analysis.

3) As a result of this (and lack of experience in the field of epidemiology) much of the data examined and analyzed by the author is misused and/or misinterpreted.


the writing is detailed as well as lucid and well-worth the reading!

in friendship,
prad
i don't know if this is the right place to post this, but a friend sent me this link, an interview w/minger about veganism and her critique. it seems clear she has an axe to grind- the site allows comments, maybe we can post some of the material showing her errors in the critique?

http://letthemeatmeat.com/post/1438446275/interview-with-an-ex-vega...
good idea, jenna!
i've mentioned your idea to some people.
if you'd like to start it off, by all means do so, though you'd probably want to start a new thread (since this should be kept for news items) within the group and we can link to it from here.

in friendship,
prad

RSS

About

TheBananaGirl created this Ning Network.

30BaD Search

Latest Activity

Rob is now a member of 30 Bananas a Day!
17 hours ago
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Alex Sunbear's discussion Seeking some fruity friends in Brooklyn/Manhattan in the group NYC and vicinity
yesterday
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Alex Sunbear's discussion Seeking some fruity friends in Brooklyn/Manhattan in the group NYC and vicinity
yesterday
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Alex Sunbear's discussion Seeking some fruity friends in Brooklyn/Manhattan in the group NYC and vicinity
yesterday
Houdini Steve Owens joined TheBananaGirl's group
yesterday
OrganicMark posted a status
"The Other Side of the “Shut Down”: Covert Operations Ongoing to Eviscerate the Deep State [videos] #truth #light #now http://bit.ly/2Fz69R1"
Friday
OrganicMark posted a status
"CONFIRMED: President Trump Can Start Laying Off Furloughed Workers After 30 Days With ‘Reduction In Force’ Procedure http://bit.ly/2RSj0DH"
Friday
ednshell replied to Raw Mormon Mommy's discussion If YOU were diagnosed with CANCER..
Wednesday
pradtf replied to pradtf's discussion great site with nutritional research information
Tuesday
Courtney Beth replied to Raw Mormon Mommy's discussion If YOU were diagnosed with CANCER..
Tuesday
OrganicMark posted a status
"What If This Puerto Rico Trip Is For "Tribunals" For 30 Democrats And 109 Lobbyists?! #peace #truth #love #light #now http://bit.ly/2suXgiY"
Tuesday
Courtney Beth replied to Roar of Tiger's discussion Can 811 rv diet heal cancer?
Tuesday
Courtney Beth replied to Dutchie's discussion Cancer on 811?
Tuesday
Houdini Steve Owens replied to Frugisaurus's discussion Looking for housemate brazil
Jan 14
Profile IconBen and Shaunta Clint joined 30 Bananas a Day!
Jan 12
Frugisaurus posted a discussion
Jan 10

© 2019   Created by TheBananaGirl.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service