Can I be honest? I think you looked like you were at a healthy weight and before and now are a bit on the too thin side. I looked just like the when I was anorexic.
To be honest, I am inclined to agree. Maybe it is just the pictures... but I would wonder if you're undereating (which is easy to do). It isn't so much the limbs but the face. Note that Freelee is pretty slim in an athletic way, but she doesn't have a gaunt look to her face.
Perhaps there is a happy middle between the two pictures...
Your creation, Win?
A great tribute to our friends :)