30 Bananas a Day!

Is my trainer messing with me? Calipers reliable for measuring body fat?

Hello there friends,

I have been HCRV for almost 5 months solid, no overts. I had my body fat percentage measured at the gym when I was about 4 weeks in, and I found out that I was at 16.1%. At that time I weighed 155lbs, I am 5'10''. 

So. Today at the gym I weighed in at 175lbs, with shoes and clothing, and am now at 25.3% body fat according to the calipers. I know that dexascan is waay better, I unfortunately do not have access to one. 

My trainer is giving me a whole lot of 'I told you so's", and telling me to go paleo. This is obviously not an option for me, or anyone else with half a brain. However, I am startingt o doubt the magic of fruit, and I am devestated to feel like this diet has failed me because I have given it all I've got for the last several months. I've been spending between $500 and $700 a month on (mostly) organic fruit. I have made many positive lifestyle changes since beginning my hcrv journey, such as quitting smoking, drinking alcohol and coffee/tea, dropping all spices and condiments, and being more active. 

How can this be? Looking for some support and any helpful information before I go donate two cases of bananas to Occupy Portland. :(((((

Respectfully,

Caitlin

Tags: fat, from, fruit?

Views: 1801

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

i saw a fellow trainer rig a scale!! to scare a fighter in thinking he was heavier. so he would cut faster. poor dude ended up in hospital and missed his first semi pro fight.

175lbs?? Well I guess you could be 8ft tall..

 

Vego UFC fighter Jake Sheilds is 170lbs...

As I said, I'm the same height as u and I just remembered that when I was 155 pds and was going to the gym regularly, my caliper tests said I was around 23% body fat. So I find it strange that u were supposedly 16% at that same weight?! 16% fat for a women is extremely low. I'd say ur trainer has screwed up ur readings and if weighed urself fully dressed this time and now being fully carbed up and hydrated, there is no wonder ur weight was higher.

The only person that gets on the scales fully clothed is Roy Nelson lol! 

The more that I have been thinking about it, I totally agree that it was probably too low of a reading. 16% is very low, and although I was smaller, I think it is unlikely that I was ever that lean. 

Something is definitely rotten in Denmark. If you had this dramatic a change, you would NOT need calipers to tell you! You would KNOW.

I'm starting to think your trainer is on a mission to prove herself right, whatever the cost to your mental health.

I can see how his interests are different from mine, and that he may have catered to his own. I mean, why would he want me to feel good about myself when I'm living a contradictory lifestyle to his. 

Stop 10 random strangers on the street and say 'doing a survey on body image for Uni, do I look fat to you?'

Look at your videos champ. You got HARDCORE body image issues if you think your fat lol!

I love it when newbies post on here and say 'IM FAT!' then you look at their photos and they are either stick insects or just floppy from decades of low fitness levels but they think its the new health food fling that is the problem....

Thank you for the clarification. I should probably go and talk to someone, like a therapist.

Body image is a tough one. Objectivity is needed to overcome the difference between how we think we look and how we actually do.

I think you look great, by the way, just going by your pics (where are these vids DR mentions?). So I suppose now you only need to stop 9 strangers. ;-)

I had my suspisions on the trainer as well, as soon as I read that he is almost forcing you to go on Paleo diet. Maybe not, I don't want to blaim anyone.

But, to check again...Do you have a chance to do your meassurements somewhere else?

Best to you! :D

I wish I had access to a better way. :(( 

RSS

30BaD search

Loading

Donations help 30BaD thrive

         Durianriders Blog

            Freelee's Blog

© 2013   Created by TheBananaGirl.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service